Home Appraisals (& How To Avoid A Low One!)

A home appraisal is a professional estimate of your home’s value and the land it's on. It reflects the home’s location, size, condition, amenities, and resent sales of nearby, comparable properties (“comps”). Lenders require home appraisals when buyers apply for a mortgage. The appraisal figure determines the loan amount buyers can get to purchase the property. Sellers can get an appraisal before listing their homes, using the Appraiser Institute site. Use this to help set an asking price, and be sure to provide a copy to your buyer’s appraiser.

Lenders hire appraisers, who are third-party, certified and/or licensed contractors. Make sure your lender hires a certified appraiser who works with multiple lenders. You may also request that the appraiser be knowledgable on the area where you live. The buyer typically pays the appraisal fee (a few hundred dollars) upon closing as a part of mortgage costs. An appraisal takes a few hours, and the report is given to the lender in about a week. The lender is required to share the report with the buyer.

Things get more complicated when the appraised value is less than the home’s asking price. Buyers cannot finance the amount that they expected to. Sellers should obtain a copy of the report and make the repairs that they can before requesting a second appraisal. Low appraisals are more common in a poor housing market due to the lack of recent comparable area home sales.

How To Avoid a Low Appraisal

Before the appraisal, spruce up your home the best you can so that its overall condition improves. This includes repairing or replacing soiled carpeting, painting over marks on the walls, mowing the lawn and pulling weeds, and removing peeling paint (since loans insured by the government require peeling paint to be removed in homes before 1978). Fix leaky faucets, cracked windows, missing handrails and structural damage. Focus on updates that will earn a high ROI: paint, carpet, light and plumbing fixtures. You want the home’s effective age—the age an appraiser can assign to a home after considering its updates and condition—to be as low as possible. This affects what homes yours will be compared to. Finally, put any pets away before the appraiser arrives and make sure your home is clean and comfortable enough for the appraiser to do his/her work.

Inform your appraiser of recent short sales or foreclosures that may affect the comps. Let the appraiser know if a nearby home was sold by owner, since this is likely not reflected in the Multiple Listing Service (MLS) from which appraisers draw their information. Also let the appraiser know of any improvements you’ve made to your home in the last 15 years. Keep a list of each update and its approximate cost (from a new roof or insulation to a bathtub that has been resealed). Additional useful information includes the property's best features and a sketch indicating square footages. If improvements have been made to the area where you live (a new playground or grocery store, for example), or if it has been declared a historic or landmark district, notify your appraiser. Click here for a sample appraisal form. 

What Percent of Asking Price Should You Offer?

Most Realtors will tell buyers that the price of a home is negotiable. However, there is no set rule for what percent of a home's asking price to offer the seller. You don't want to overpay, but an offer too low may offend the seller. Your offer price should depend on a number of factors, including:

The appraised value. Whereas asking prices are determined by sellers and their real estate agents, home appraisals are determined by third-party professionals. They can help you determine the true value of a home.

The housing market. If the housing market favors sellers over buyers, you'll need to offer more in order to remain competitive.  Paying in cash also increases the competitiveness of offers. This situation is somewhat true of today's housing market, in which limited supply does not meet the high demand. Sales of nearby comparable homes can help you evaluate the market, which varies geographically.

Seller motivation. How eager is the current owner of a home to sell it? Consider a family that has been relocated due to a parent's career. The family has already moved, but its prior home is still on the market. Considering the family is losing money on maintaining the home, and not deriving any benefit, a lower offer stands a better chance than it might for a family that has not yet moved and faces little time pressure.

How long the house has been on the market. This is linked to seller motivation. The longer the house sits on the market, the more work it is for the owners to constantly clean it for showings, consult with their Realtor, etc. Also, sellers who are eager to move will likely grow impatient if buyers do not show interest in their house. Therefore, generally speaking, the longer a home sits on the market, the more likely its owner(s) will be to accept a lower offer.

Overall, many Realtors advise buyers to offer at least 90% of the asking price. However, as noted above, this figure is dependent on many moving parts. In some markets, buyers may even find it necessary to make offers above the asking price. This is one of the reasons that having an experienced Realtor familiar with the area in which you are buying is so crucial. Interested in buying or selling a home in Central Ohio? Contact me to see how I can help!